A crisis year for web standards
Lee January 7th, 2008
Recent news from the web standards arena has not been pleasant to my ears. The HTML5 group has rejected open media standards. Andy Clarke has called for the CSS Working Group to be disbanded, while others want to drop the W3C altogether.
Do standards hold us back from innovation, or do they provide the discipline to keep the web from shattering into a million proprietary fiefdoms? Through the years of bringing discipline into the programming field, many spoke harshly against the new restrictions on our “style”, and only now, so many years later, can we see how the discipline saved programming, turning it from an arcane art to a true science, a discipline, and gave it the ability to handle the truly large projects that are so common today.
We could never have these incredible operating systems, Windows, Mac, and Linux, bloated though they may seem, without the involvement of incredible disciplines to define interfaces between modules. We could never have all these open source free applications without the disciplines that allow the coordination of work by multiple people, separated by time and space, to work together on fantastically complex projects. If you doubt my words, go read Fred Brooks’ “The Mythical Man Month”, written back in 1975. It is well worth the read today.
Some folks see the disciplining process as an affront to their own personal creativity, but the truly creative among us know that discipline is the key to real creativity. Read any of Ansel Adams’ books about photographic creativity and you will find a strict discipline of methods and procedures underlying all his wonderful work. The beauty of modern architectural miracles could never coalesce without the structural engineering that gives it strength.
If the web is ever to live up to its true promise, it will be the disciplines of standards that will lead it to those fields of dreams. To abandon the process now because it is slow and difficult, or because it is not going in just the direction you personally would have it go, is to betray the dream, the promise of an incredible means of bringing people together, and ultimately of promoting peace among all people and nations.
Just one man’s opinion,
__________________
Lee Eschen
Ashgrove Visual Arts
~~~
“Vision without technique is blind.” –George Lepp